H1

Three Questions

Honeycomb (Prose) β€’ Author: Leo Tolstoy β€” A king searches for the answers to the three most vital questions in life

Chapter Summary & Core Theme
A certain king believed that he would never fail if he knew the right time to begin everything, the right people to listen to, and the most important thing to do. He proclaimed a great reward, but the answers from wise men were diverse and contradictory. Disappointed, the king visited a wise hermit living in a forest. While the king helped the frail hermit dig flower beds, an injured, bleeding man ran towards them. The king washed and bandaged his severe stomach wound, saving his life. The man revealed he was the king's sworn enemy who came to assassinate him, but was wounded by the king's bodyguard. Overwhelmed by the king's mercy, the enemy asked for forgiveness and pledged loyalty. The hermit then revealed the answers: The most important time is NOW (the present moment); the most important person is the one you are currently with; and the most important deed is to do good to that person.
🎯 Central Theme: The importance of living in the present moment, listening to conscience, and performing acts of benevolence to humanity.
πŸ“– Intext Comprehension Checks
Comprehension Check β€” Page 10 (Q1)
Why did the king want to know answers to three questions?
2 Marks
Detailed Solution

The king wanted to know the answers to the three questions because he believed that if he always knew:

1. What was the right time to begin everything,
2. Who were the right people to listen to (and whom to avoid), and
3. What was the most important thing for him to do,
he would never fail in any undertaking or governance in his life.
CBSE Step-by-Step Marking Scheme
Desire to achieve infallible governance and never fail 1 Mark
Identifying the 3 specific criteria (time, people, action) 1 Mark
Comprehension Check β€” Page 10 (Q2)
Messengers were sent throughout the kingdom:
(i) to fetch wise men.
(ii) to find answers to the questions.
(iii) to look for the wise hermit.
(iv) to announce a reward for those who could answer the questions.
Choose the correct option.
1 Mark
Detailed Solution

Correct Option: (iv) to announce a reward for those who could answer the questions.

Textual Proof: The king sent messengers throughout his kingdom promising a large sum of money to anyone who would answer these three questions satisfactorily.
CBSE Step-by-Step Marking Scheme
Correct selection: option (iv) 1 Mark
Comprehension Check β€” Page 14 (Q1)
Who was the bearded man who came running out of the woods? Why did he ask for the king's forgiveness?
3 Marks
Detailed Solution
1. Identity of the Bearded Man: The bearded man was the king's sworn enemy. The king had previously executed his brother and seized his ancestral property, so the man had resolved to ambush and assassinate the king on his return journey from the hermit's hut.
2. Reason for Asking Forgiveness: When the king's bodyguards recognized and wounded him, he escaped to the hermit's hut where he would have bled to death. The king, unaware of his identity, tirelessly washed and bandaged his severe wound and gave him fresh water, saving his life. Overwhelmed with remorse that the man he came to kill had saved his life, he asked for the king's forgiveness and promised lifelong faithful servitude.
CBSE Step-by-Step Marking Scheme
Identification as sworn enemy seeking vengeance for brother and property 1.5 Marks
Remorse and gratitude because the king saved his life instead of killing him 1.5 Marks
✍️ Working with the Text
Working with the Text β€” Q1
Why was the king advised to go to magicians?
2 Marks
Detailed Solution
In reply to the first question (the right time for every action), some wise men argued that to decide the right time for doing something, one must look into the future. Since only magicians possess the supernatural power to look into the future, they advised the king that he would have to consult magicians to know the right time for every action.
CBSE Step-by-Step Marking Scheme
Need to know the future to decide the right time 1 Mark
Magicians being the only ones believed capable of foreseeing future 1 Mark
Working with the Text β€” Q2
In answer to the second question, whose advice did the people say would be important to the king?
2 Marks
Detailed Solution
In response to the second question (who were the right people to listen to), the wise men gave varying opinions:
  • Some said the king's councillors were the most necessary advisors.
  • Others suggested the priests (clergy) were the most important.
  • A few recommended doctors for maintaining life and health.
  • Yet others claimed that his soldiers (warriors) were the most essential for defense and conquest.
CBSE Step-by-Step Marking Scheme
Listing councillors, priests, doctors, and soldiers 2 Marks
Working with the Text β€” Q3
What suggestions were made in answer to the third question?
2 Marks
Detailed Solution
In answer to the third question (what was the most important thing to do / occupation):
  • Some wise men asserted that the pursuit of science was the most important business.
  • Others chose skill in warfare and military strategy.
  • Still others maintained that religious worship and prayer was the highest priority.
CBSE Step-by-Step Marking Scheme
Science, warfare, and religious worship accurately stated 2 Marks
Working with the Text β€” Q4
Did the wise men win the reward? If not, why not?
2 Marks
Detailed Solution
No, none of the wise men won the reward.
Reason: Their answers were so diverse, contradictory, and conflicting that the king could not agree with any of them. Since no answer proved convincing or satisfying to his intellect, the king gave the reward to no one.
CBSE Step-by-Step Marking Scheme
Negative response (No reward given) 1 Mark
Contradictory and unconvincing nature of the diverse answers 1 Mark
Working with the Text β€” Q5
How did the king and the hermit help the wounded man?
3 Marks
Detailed Solution
1. The king unfastened the wounded man's clothing and discovered a large bleeding wound in his stomach.
2. The king washed the wound thoroughly and covered it with his own handkerchief and a towel provided by the hermit.
3. When blood continued to flow profusely, the king re-dressed the wound repeatedly until the bleeding finally ceased.
4. The king then brought fresh drinking water to revive the parched man.
5. As darkness fell and the air turned cool, the king and the hermit carried the wounded man inside the hut and laid him comfortably on the bed to rest safely overnight.
CBSE Step-by-Step Marking Scheme
Washing and re-dressing the stomach wound with handkerchief/towel 1.5 Marks
Providing fresh water and carrying him to rest on hermit's bed 1.5 Marks
Working with the Text β€” Q6
What were the hermit's answers to the three questions? Write each answer separately. Which answer do you like most, and why?
5 Marks
Detailed Solution
The Hermit's Answers:
1. The Right Time: The most important time is NOW (the present moment). It is the only time over which human beings possess any actual control or power to act.
2. The Right Person: The most important person is the person you are with at any particular moment, for no one knows whether they will ever meet anyone else in the future.
3. The Most Important Thing to Do: The most important business is to do good to the person you are with, because humanity was sent into this earthly life for that sole purpose.
Personal Preference & Justification:
I like the answer regarding the present time (NOW) the most. People often waste precious life regretting the unchangeable past or worrying anxiously about the uncertain future. Focusing entirely on the present moment empowers us to act ethically, solve problems immediately, and live meaningful, productive lives.
CBSE Step-by-Step Marking Scheme
First question: Time is NOW (present moment) 1 Mark
Second question: Person you are currently with 1 Mark
Third question: Doing good to that person 1 Mark
Personal choice with thoughtful philosophical reasoning 2 Marks
Working with Language β€” Ex 3
Use the following idioms and phrases in sentences of your own:
(i) in place of    (ii) look after    (iii) tired of    (iv) forgive and forget
4 Marks (1 Mark each)
Detailed Solution
(i) in place of: Reena was appointed team captain in place of the injured player.
(ii) look after: It is our moral duty to look after our elderly parents and grandparents with love.
(iii) tired of: After hiking for six hours through the dense hills, the trekkers were thoroughly tired of walking.
(iv) forgive and forget: True nobility lies in the willingness to forgive and forget past grievances and begin afresh.
CBSE Step-by-Step Marking Scheme
Grammatically sound and meaningful sentence for each phrase 1 Mark each
πŸ’‘ Competency-Based & HOTS Questions (CBSE 2026-27 Pattern) Analytical Thinking
Competency-Based Case Study: Practical Ethics
In modern corporate leadership and daily student life, how does Leo Tolstoy's philosophy of 'The Three Questions' help reduce anxiety and build empathetic relationships?

Tolstoy's philosophy provides two transformative life principles:

  1. Mindfulness over Multitasking: By realizing that the only real time is 'NOW', students avoid cognitive overload and procrastination. They focus deeply on the task at hand rather than future exam anxieties.
  2. Empathetic Human Relations: Treating the person standing in front of you as the most important individual fosters active listening, kindness, and deep mutual respect in families, friendships, and workplaces.
HOTS / Value-Based Question
How did the king turn an assassination attempt into an enduring lifelong alliance of friendship?

The king exemplified the transformative power of forgiveness and compassion. Instead of executing his enemy when he discovered his identity, the king treated his wounds with tenderness, promised his royal physicians would care for him, and restored his confiscated property. Compassion disarmed hatred, proving that love conquers enmity far more permanently than military force.